Disclaimer:
Property information, valuations, estimates, and other data provided on this website are for informational purposes only. They are not intended for use in financial, legal, lending, appraisal, or other official transactions. Users should independently verify all information with the appropriate government agencies, licensed professionals, or other authoritative sources.
Property Info
44381 Hillcrest Ave
Shaver Lake,
CA
$537,000
Last Sale Price
Bedrooms
3.00
Bathrooms
2.00
Building Sqft
1,733
Price / Sqft
$309.87
Property Information
APN
12028415
Land Use
Single Family Residential - Not Vacant & Planned Unit Dev & Condos-res
Use Code
11
Zoning Code
-
Zoning
-
Property Type
Residential
Property Subtype
Single Family Residence
Year Built
1955
Lot Size
6,000 sqft
Pool
0
Spa
0
Fire place
0
Garage Sqft./Garage Spaces
- / 0
Last Record Date
2019-11-06
Last Deed Type
01
Owner
Celaya Theodore J & Marlena Y
Partitions
Property Features
Construction
Foundation -
Roof
-
Building Material
-
Utilities
Heating -
Cooling
-
Water
-
Sewer
-
Lot
Topography -
View
-
Sales History
$537,000
2019-11-06 00:00:00
CELAYA THEODORE J & MARLENA Y
$499,000
2016-09-15 00:00:00
GARTON JEFFREY D & KRISTLE M
$0
2007-03-16 00:00:00
JOHNSON SCOTT L & KAREN L TRUSTEES
$249,900
2002-08-29 00:00:00
JOHNSON SCOTT L & KAREN L
$142,500
1997-06-27 00:00:00
BAGDASARIAN ROBERT A & DEBRA J
$115,000
1993-08-13 00:00:00
LARIMER GERALDINE G
Tax & Valuation History
Base Year:
2011
•
~ Estimated Tax
2024
$587,285
▲
$11,515
(2.00%)
~$7,459
Estimated Tax
2023
$575,770
▲
$11,289
(2.00%)
~$7,312
Estimated Tax
2022
$564,481
▲
$11,067
(2.00%)
~$6,887
Estimated Tax
2021
$553,414
▲
$10,851
(2.00%)
$6,918
Estimated Tax
2020
$542,563
▲
$5,563
(1.04%)
$6,782
Estimated Tax
2019
$537,000
▲
$17,841
(3.44%)
$6,713
Estimated Tax
2018
$519,159
▲
$20,159
(4.04%)
$6,489
Estimated Tax
2017
$499,000
▲
$0
(0.00%)
$5,362
Estimated Tax
2016
$499,000
▲
$198,338
(65.97%)
~$5,788
Estimated Tax
2015
$300,662
▲
$5,889
(2.00%)
$3,233
Estimated Tax
2014
$294,773
▲
$17,473
(6.30%)
$3,175
Estimated Tax
2013
$277,300
▲
$25,200
(10.00%)
$2,988
Estimated Tax
2012
$252,100
▼
$13,400
(5.05%)
$2,734
Estimated Tax
2011
Base Year
$265,500
$2,855
Estimated Tax
Investment Score
Historical sales activity and market conditions may provide insight into the property's long-term value. The property has 6 recorded sale transactions.
Overall Score
55
Appreciation Score
50
Cash Flow Score
50
Tax Score
50
School Score
50
Growth Score
50
Liquidity Score
75
Investment Grade
C+
Model Version
v1
Generated
Jul 07, 2026
Market Analysis
City
Shaver Lake
Sales Count
6
Schools Count
1
Estimated Value
$417,633
Low Estimate
$388,921
High Estimate
$446,345
Median Area Price
$420,000.00
Median Price / SqFt
$243.06
Confidence Score
89%
Comparable Properties
16
Neighborhood Growth
0.00%
Market Trend
Balanced
1-Year Appreciation
-3.33%
3-Year Appreciation
-10.00%
5-Year Appreciation
-16.67%
Generated
Jul 07, 2026
Market Snapshot
Snapshot Date
Jul 07, 2026
Estimated Value
$417,633
Low Valuation
$375,870
High Valuation
$459,396
Confidence Score
89.00%
Model Version
v1
Generated
Jul 07, 2026
Property Market Snapshot
Estimated Market Value
$417,633
Range:
$388,921
–
$446,345
Confidence
89%
Assessment
$587,285
Difference
-
$169,652
(28.9%)
1 Year
-3.3%
3 Year
-10.0%
5 Year
-16.7%
Market
Balanced
Comparables
16
Sales Used
Area Median
$420,000
Median $/SqFt
$243
Area Growth
+
0.0%
Updated
Schools
Elementary School
Big Creeksierra Hills Unified
High School
Sierra Hills Unified
School District
Sierra Hills Unified
Nearby Properties
44367 Hillcrest Ave
0
miles away
Single Family Residential - Not Vacant & Planned Unit Dev & Condos-res
44369 Hillcrest Ave
0
miles away
Single Family Residential - Not Vacant & Planned Unit Dev & Condos-res
44354 Hillcrest Ave
0
miles away
Single Family Residential - Not Vacant & Planned Unit Dev & Condos-res
44366 Hillcrest Ave
0
miles away
Single Family Residential - Not Vacant & Planned Unit Dev & Condos-res
44378 Hillcrest Ave
0
miles away
Single Family Residential - Not Vacant & Planned Unit Dev & Condos-res
44383 Hillcrest Ave
0
miles away
Single Family Residential - Not Vacant & Planned Unit Dev & Condos-res
44422 Hillcrest
0.01
miles away
Single Family Residential - Not Vacant & Planned Unit Dev & Condos-res
44415 Hillcrest
0.01
miles away
Single Family Residential - Not Vacant & Planned Unit Dev & Condos-res
44432 Hillcrest
0.02
miles away
Single Family Residential - Not Vacant & Planned Unit Dev & Condos-res
44402 Hillcrest
0.03
miles away
Single Family Residential - Not Vacant & Planned Unit Dev & Condos-res
Median Home Price
$420,000
Median sale price in ZIP
Buyer Score
Located in Shaver Lake. This property may appeal to buyers seeking a residential opportunity.
Not enough data to generate a Buyer Score.
We couldn't generate a reliable Buyer Score for this property due to insufficient market data.
We couldn't generate a reliable Buyer Score for this property due to insufficient market data.
Seller Score
The property is located in Shaver Lake.
Seller Score
67/100
Quick Sale Price
$396,751.43
Recommended Price
$417,633.08
Premium Price
$438,514.73
Sale Probability (30 Days)
47%
Sale Probability (60 Days)
53%
Sale Probability (90 Days)
59%
Market Timing Score
50/100
Generated
Jul 07, 2026
Comparable Sales
16 Found